Dangerous, Not Evil? Writing characters with moral complexity
The first time my heroine meets Samuel Asmodeus, he has a sword at her throat. Then he asks her why he let a child live.
I didn’t write him to be liked. I wrote him to be understood, which is far more dangerous.
Over 47 years of life, I have accumulated, like most women, a fairly substantial catalogue of male characters.
Men who have been colleagues, family members and bosses. Men I have lived with and travelled with. Doctors, tradesmen, fathers, gay men, soldiers, teachers, farmers, and just men sitting down the pub.
Some experiences were good. Some were very bad. Over time, you begin to notice things. You notice the difference between someone who needs everyone to know he holds the power and someone who does not. You notice who becomes louder when challenged, who becomes quieter, who protects people when there is nothing to gain from it, and who uses authority simply because they can.
You also learn that people capable of intimidation, violence or terrible decisions are not necessarily simple people.
That gave me a very large, very personal pool of inspiration when I began building Sam.
Where Sam began
Sam is not simply a capable man. He carries an underlying threat that most women become aware of at some point in their lives. We don’t particularly like talking about it.
Physical power exists. Violence exists. The possibility of violence exists.
But there is an uncomfortable other side to that equation. Sometimes the same capacity that makes a person dangerous is the capacity we desperately need when something goes wrong. Jordan Peterson has spoken about the idea that being harmless is not the same as being good. His argument, broadly, is that a person capable of being dangerous, but able to control that capacity voluntarily, has something different from simple harmlessness.
“A harmless man is not a good man. A good man is a very, very dangerous man who has that under voluntary control.”
That idea stuck with me. Can somebody be a moral person and still be a monster?
And maybe the more uncomfortable question is this: what happens when the person capable of protecting you is also the person you may need protection from?

That is where Sam began getting interesting to me.
“Maybe I needed a monster.”
The last few years of my own life have been difficult, and 2026 in particular has been challenging.
I’ll give you the smallest example. Over and over, on project after project, the biggest obstacle hasn’t been the work. It’s been the question. “Can I speak with your husband?” “Could I have a quick word with your dad?” I’m the one running the project, and the man in front of me is looking past me for someone he thinks actually holds the power. Because of how I look, I smile, keep going, and prove it all over again. You learn what it feels like to be the most capable person in the room and the last one anyone asks.
While I was working on the novel, my AI, Bishop, joked that perhaps I had created Samuel Asmodeus because he was strong enough to change his circumstances while I felt I was barely being given a breath’s chance to change mine.
That stayed with me, because there was some truth in it. When everything around you feels unstable, there is something psychologically seductive about a character with enormous agency.
Sam acts.
He makes decisions.
He changes the conditions around him.
He does not wait for a committee, an employer, an institution or somebody else to decide whether he is allowed to move.
So it’s possible I manufactured somebody who could. Someone who could step into chaos and control it, while everyone else was still discussing what should be done. I know how it feels to be powerless. Maybe, for a little while, I needed my hero to be a monster. So I took pieces of what I had observed over a lifetime and put them into one man. The good parts. The frightening parts. The contradictions.
And then I gave him power.
Restraint
The most important quality I gave Sam was restraint. Danger by itself isn’t particularly interesting. A character who answers every problem with violence quickly becomes predictable, and once you know what he’ll do, the tension is gone. The more interesting character is someone who could destroy the room and chooses to sit quietly.
Here’s an early moment from the book. Gabby, a researcher who should not be able to reach him, has stepped into his path. His sword is already at her throat when he tests her:
‘When I rode back from the village this morning,’ he continued, voice calm, ‘I passed a boy hiding beneath a cart. He held a knife meant for my horse. He did not strike. I saw him. I let him live.’ His eyes locked onto hers. ‘Why?’ ‘Because he was afraid,’ she said quietly. ‘He wasn’t brave or stupid. Just afraid. And because killing him would have changed nothing about the situation.’
That’s Sam. He can kill, and he chooses not to. That choice is the whole point.
Author Lee Child has talked about Jack Reacher as a form of wish fulfilment. Reacher can step into an unjust situation and do what ordinary people can’t. He isn’t held back by a workplace, a bureaucracy, fear of consequences, or the thousand practical things that stop real people from intervening.
I understand the appeal completely. But for Sam, that was a little too tidy for me. With Reacher, you can stand comfortably beside him and think, Yes. That was the right thing to do.
Life has never looked that clean to me. I wanted the line to blur. How far can somebody go before dangerous becomes evil? If somebody does something terrible for a reason you understand, does understanding the reason change the act? What if you agree with the outcome but are horrified by the method? What if the person who solves the problem is more frightening than the problem itself?
That was far more interesting to me than writing a conventional hero.
Sam has rules
Morally complex characters need an internal logic. What will they protect? What will they tolerate? What crosses a line? What will they never forgive?
Their rules don’t need to resemble ours, but they need to make sense to them. Sam is bound by rules just like the rest of us. The difference is in how he interprets them, and sometimes how he manipulates them.
Most of us are restrained by several layers at once. Law. Morality. Social expectations. Fear. Reputation. Consequence. Our relationships with other people. Even when we’ve reached our final straw, there are things most of us simply will not do.
Sam’s boundaries sit somewhere else. That raised a question I kept returning to while writing him:
who stops someone like this?

Often, nobody does, and maybe that’s what makes him unsettling. Someone without rules is simply chaos. The real terror is someone with a very clear set of rules that make perfect sense to him. Sam can explain himself. His reasoning is internally consistent. You may even understand exactly why he made a decision.
And still find yourself thinking: Jesus Christ, Sam.
Contradictions
I never wanted Sam to be one thing, because people generally aren’t. Someone can be brutal and protective, patient and terrifying, intelligent and emotionally difficult. Loyal without being good. Compassionate without being safe.
We’ve all seen how someone can love another person and still frighten them. Someone can believe they’re protecting another person while taking away that person’s ability to choose.
Those qualities don’t cancel each other out. They exist together. That’s why I didn’t want readers asking, Is Sam good or bad? I wanted that question to become inconsequential.
I wanted them asking: What will he choose, and why?
Understanding is not excusing
Understanding a morally difficult character doesn’t require forgiving him. I don’t need a reader to finish one of Sam’s decisions and think, Sam was right.
I’d much rather they think: I understand exactly why he did that, and I still don’t know how I feel about it.
That uncertainty is valuable. Real people rarely fit the categories fiction gives us. Hero. Villain. Good man. Bad man. Monster. Protector. Sometimes the same person occupies several of those spaces, depending on where you’re standing.
Dangerous is easy. Evil is easy. It’s everything between them that interested me.
What I was really asking
The easiest way to write a dangerous character is to make him violent. The harder thing is making the reader believe he could be dangerous while he’s sitting perfectly still. Maybe that’s what I was exploring all along.
When you’ve experienced powerlessness, does power itself start to look virtuous?

I don’t think the answer is simply yes. Power can protect, but it can also dominate. Strength can make someone feel safe, and the very same strength can make them dangerous. Restraint matters precisely because the capacity to do harm is still there.
I gave him the power to act when I felt powerless. Then I gave him enough humanity to make me question what he would do with it.
So the question was never whether they’re good or evil. It’s how much power we’re prepared to forgive when it’s being used on our side.
If Sam sounds like someone you’d want to argue about, Silent Century is out now on Amazon.
A dark historical sci-fi romance of war, faith and forbidden love. Some doors should stay closed. Blending historical fiction, psychological thriller, speculative science fiction and dark philosophical mystery, Silent Century explores consciousness, time, power and the cost of opening doors that were never meant to be touched.




Comments